Slab vs Shaker Cabinets: Style, Cost, and Durability Compared
Slab and shaker cabinets are two of the most popular styles for residential and commercial renovation projects. The styles are both simple, versatile, and elegant. There are a variety of finishes and materials available for both styles, so you can completely customize the look of a space. When deciding between slab vs. shaker cabinets, it's best to take some time to compare the style, cost, and durability to find the best solution for you.
In this article, we'll explore the differences in-depth to help determine which style is best for you.
Understanding Slab and Shaker Cabinets
Slab and shaker cabinets have unique stylistic differences. Here's how both styles compare:
What Are Slab Cabinets?
Featured Cabinet Doors
Slab cabinet doors are commonly referred to as flat-panel doors. This style has a completely flat surface without a frame and is available in solid wood, medium-density fiberboard, and thermally fused laminate (TFL). The simple, minimalist design works with sleek, modern aesthetics. It's a top choice for minimalist, Scandinavian, modern, and contemporary kitchens.
What Are Shaker Cabinets?
Featured Cabinet Doors
Shaker cabinet doors feature a five-piece frame with a recessed center panel. It has a simple structure that lacks ornate details, elegantly combining a classic style with modern simplicity. Shaker cabinet doors complement traditional, farmhouse, and transitional kitchen designs. The style is also available in solid wood and medium-density fiberboard.
Style Differences Between Slab & Shaker Cabinets
When deciding between slab vs. shaker cabinet doors, ensure the style complements your aesthetic vision. Here's how the styles compare aesthetically:
|
Type |
Construction |
Aesthetic |
Detailing |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Shaker Cabinet Doors |
Framed panel with recessed center |
Timeless and versatile |
Subtle detailing with the frame |
|
Slab Cabinet Doors |
Flat panel with no frame |
Minimalist and modern |
Lacks ornate details |
Cost Comparison: Slab vs Shaker Cabinets
Slab cabinet doors are flat, single-panel doors that require minimal craftsmanship, which is why they tend to be a more affordable option. However, pricing can vary depending on material and finish. Here are a few examples of how prices can vary.
|
Type |
Painted |
Beech |
Unfinished Medium-Density Fiberboard |
|
Shaker Cabinet Doors |
$30.00 / sq ft. |
$27.08 / sq ft |
$17.95 / sq ft. |
|
Slab Cabinet Doors |
$30.00 / sq ft. |
$23.08 / sq ft. |
$14.00 / sq ft. |
Factors That Influence Slab and Shaker Cabinet Prices
The cost between slab vs. shaker cabinets can vary, depending on several factors. Here are the factors you'll need to consider while budgeting:
Material
Solid wood is typically more expensive than MDF and veneer. The cost of solid wood can also vary depending on species. For example, knotty alder is a more affordable wood species for cabinet doors than white oak.
Finish
Ordering finished doors is more expensive than unfinished cabinet doors. While unfinished cabinet doors are a cheaper alternative, they will require more DIYing at home before installing.
Labor
If you decide to hire professionals to help with the installation, you'll need to factor this into the cost. Doing the installation process yourself can help you save on expenses.
Craftsmanship
While investing in a custom-made solution may be more expensive than a big box retailer, the craftsmanship and quality will be better. This will increase the longevity of your replacement cabinet doors.
Durability & Maintenance for Shaker and Slab Cabinets
When purchased from a trusted supplier, shaker and slab cabinet doors are both long-lasting options for your next home renovation project. Here's how they compare:
How They Hold Up Over Time
Shaker cabinet doors are typically crafted of solid wood and tend to be more durable than slab cabinet doors. Slab cabinet doors are traditionally made of medium-density fiberboard, a budget-friendly alternative to solid wood. MDF has a flat surface that's great for painting.
Cleaning & Upkeep
Slab cabinet doors lack grooves or edges, making them easier to clean. To maintain a pristine look, regularly wipe them down with a gentle soap and water. Dirt and grime can build up in the grooves of shaker cabinet doors and may require extra care and attention.
Which Cabinet Style Is Right for You?
If you prefer the minimalist style that's easy to maintain, slab cabinet doors are a great choice for your renovation project. The structure is simple in design and complements modern aesthetics.
If you prefer a timeless style that will complement your kitchen no matter how your design preferences change, shaker cabinet doors are a great alternative.
Mixing Slab and Shaker Cabinets in One Kitchen
Do you like the look of shaker cabinet doors but don't have the budget? Consider installing shaker cabinet doors on the upper cabinets and slab cabinet doors on the lower cabinets. This is an affordable way to ensure shaker cabinet doors are the focal point of the space. For a more cohesive look, consider sticking with one or the other.
Choosing Between Slab and Shaker Cabinets for Your Kitchen
Slab and shaker cabinet doors are two popular choices for commercial and residential renovations. When exploring the different types, consider your unique style preference for your space.
At Cabinet Door Factory, we offer a variety of materials, finishes, and wood types available for both slab and shaker cabinet doors. We also have matching drawer fronts and glass-ready options to complete the look.
Explore our collection of cabinet door styles today to find the perfect match.
FAQs About Slab & Shaker Cabinets
Can I get slab and shaker cabinet doors in the same custom size?
Yes, slab and shaker cabinet doors from Cabinet Door Factory are custom-made and made to fit the provided measurements. Use our measurement guide to ensure you get accurate measurements before placing your order.
Are slab or shaker cabinets easier to repair if damaged?
Slab cabinet doors have a simple construction and are typically easier to repair than shaker cabinet doors. Scratches, dents, and imperfections can be filled in with wood filler or paint if needed.
Can slab and shaker cabinet doors be bought finished or unfinished?
Yes, slab and shaker cabinet doors are available to order finished and unfinished on our website.
